A headteacher suspending 25 pupils in a single week over behaviour reportedly including laughing and zipping up bags has raised an important question for parents: Can a school really suspend a child for something that seems so minor? The answer depends on the circumstances, the school’s behaviour policy and what actually happened — not simply on how trivial an incident might sound in a headline.
For families, the story also highlights a wider issue: how school behaviour rules work, when suspensions are justified and what parents can do if they believe a punishment is unfair.
Contents
What actually happened at Frome Community College?
The controversy centres on Frome Community College, where interim principal Dan Jeffries introduced a stricter approach to behaviour at the start of the new school year.
According to ITV News, 25 pupils were suspended during the first week of term. Some parents said their children had been punished for nervous laughter, making too much noise while zipping up bags or looking out of classroom windows.
Jeffries disputed the suggestion that pupils were suspended for isolated, minor actions. He said the suspensions were for persistent disruption and explained that the school’s policy required pupils to be defiant and disruptive four times before suspension would be considered.
He also said the college had recorded 20 days of suspensions during the week, with some pupils receiving more than one day. The school has around 1,400 pupils, according to his account.
The distinction matters: parents’ accounts and the principal’s explanation describe the incidents differently. The publicly reported information does not establish the full circumstances of every individual suspension.
Can a school suspend a pupil for laughing or making noise?
In England, headteachers can suspend pupils for behaviour that breaches the school’s behaviour policy. However, a suspension is a formal disciplinary measure, not simply another name for a detention or being sent out of class.
The Department for Education’s statutory guidance on suspensions and permanent exclusions sets out the framework schools must follow. A headteacher should consider the circumstances of the incident, the pupil’s conduct and relevant individual needs when deciding whether suspension is appropriate.
A pupil laughing once, accidentally making a noise or briefly looking away from a lesson is not automatically grounds for suspension. The context matters, particularly if the behaviour is repeated, deliberately disruptive or continues after staff have intervened.
Parents should also understand that a school having the power to suspend does not mean every suspension is automatically fair or justified.
Why the story raises questions about special educational needs
One of the concerns raised by parents at Frome Community College is how stricter behaviour rules affect pupils with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).
Natalie Morris told ITV News that her daughter, who has additional and sensory needs, was suspended after nervous laughter during her first week. She said the experience made returning to school difficult for her child.
This raises a broader question for families: can behaviour that appears disruptive actually be linked to a child’s needs?
Some pupils may struggle with sensory overload, anxiety, communication or attention. Schools should consider whether behaviour could be connected to an underlying need and whether reasonable adjustments or additional support are appropriate.
That does not mean pupils with SEND cannot face consequences for behaviour. It means decisions should take account of their circumstances rather than applying rules without considering individual needs.
Common misconceptions about school suspensions
Myth: A headteacher can suspend a pupil for absolutely anything.
Schools have disciplinary powers, but suspensions must follow the relevant legal framework and guidance. Parents can ask for the reasons behind a decision.
Myth: Every suspension reported in the news tells the whole story.
Headlines often condense complicated incidents. In this case, parents’ descriptions and the principal’s explanation differ, and the full details of each case have not been established in the reporting.
Myth: Parents cannot challenge a suspension.
Parents can ask the school to explain its decision and request a review through the appropriate governing board or academy trust process, depending on the circumstances.
What should parents do if their child is suspended?
If your child receives a suspension, start by asking the school for a clear explanation of what happened.
- Request the suspension letter and the specific reasons for the decision.
- Ask which part of the school’s behaviour policy was breached and what evidence was considered.
- If your child has SEND, ask how their needs and any existing support arrangements were taken into account.
- Check the school’s complaints procedure and the current Department for Education guidance to understand the available review options.
- Keep copies of correspondence and make a note of relevant conversations.
If the explanation remains unclear, contact the headteacher or the school’s designated complaints contact. For advice about SEND-related concerns, families can also approach their local SEND information, advice and support service.
What happens next?
The Frome College dispute highlights the tension schools face between maintaining orderly classrooms and ensuring that behaviour policies are applied fairly to individual pupils.
Some parents have criticised the new approach, while another parent interviewed by ITV News supported the emphasis on enforcing school rules.
The key issue is not simply how many pupils were suspended, but whether each decision was justified, proportionate and consistent with the school’s responsibilities.
For parents, the practical takeaway is straightforward: ask for the facts, understand the school’s policy and make sure your child’s individual circumstances are properly considered before concluding a headline.